The Evolution of The Black Keys

17 May
The Black Keys. Such a cool pic.

The Black Keys. Such a cool pic.

On Wednesday, the day after “Turn Blue” came out, I downloaded the new album by The Black Keys, my favorite band. As each song was downloaded I felt a sense of both excitement and nervousness. Excitement to finally hear the new material by a band that I love. Nervousness because their previous album, “El Camino”, had fewer good songs than bad songs. The first single from “Turn Blue”, a song called “Fever”, was dissappointing the first time I heard it. The predominant sound on the song is the keyboard, rather than the guitar or the drums. Black Keys fans tend to like the band because they reassure us that rock and roll is not dead, that with each driving guitar riff and pounding drumbeat the anarchic spirit of rock and roll lives on. “El Camino” for me was mostly a disappointment, anchored by that bland nothing of a single, “Lonely Boy”. So what’s the verdict on “Turn Blue”?

I’ve listened to it a few times already, and I would say half of the songs are inspired, either solid rock ballads or lovely slower songs. The Black Keys have always done slow tunes quite well: one of my all-time favorites is “Keep your hands off her” from Chulahoma, the album of Junior Kimbrough covers. That song is practically a lullaby. So the title track “Turn Blue” is a highlight for me, with its lilting surf rock grooves, and those plaintive lyrics. One of the things I love the most about The Black Keys is the sexuality of their music. I have little patience for nasty rap songs that describe the mechanics in detail. That is not sexy. But to hear Dan Auerbach wail “My heart’s on fire/With a strange desire”, on “Strange Desire” conveys sexual desire better than most. The song “Turn Blue”, with its whisper of “I really don’t think you know/There could be hell/Below”, is a standout for me.

The not-so-great half of the album are throwaways, and make me wonder if this is really the best that Patrick and Dan had to offer. The last track, “Gotta Get Away”, is so forgettable. It simply doesn’t pulse with the same energy as the stronger tracks. Is this the doing of Danger Mouse? Has he carefully been smoothing out The Black Keys’ edges over the last couple of albums? One common thread in all the albums, going back to “The Big Come Up”, is the rawness of The Black Keys’ sound. And yes, it has been softened over the years, to its creative apex on “Brothers”, where they threaded the needle perfectly between mainstream success and their trademark bluesy sound. I hope that the Keys continue to innovate and evolve as they have on “Turn Blue”, yet still maintain that libidinous edge that their fans have come to know and love.

What would a post about my favorite band be without some music? As mentioned above, here is “Keep your hands off her” from “Chulahoma”:

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: